What Happens During a Tax Audit? A Guide for Business Owners

Tax & Business

What Happens During a Tax Audit? A Guide for Business Owners

Pace Advisory GroupUpdated November 20263 min read
The short answer

An ATO audit usually starts with a letter or phone call asking for information about specific items, such as income, GST or deductions. You provide records, the ATO reviews them, and then it either closes the case or proposes changes, which can include extra tax, interest and penalties. Most reviews are about a few specific issues, not your whole life. Good records and early advice make the biggest difference.

Types of ATO contact

TypeWhat it means
Data-matching letterThe ATO’s data does not match your return. You are asked to explain or amend
ReviewThe ATO checks specific risks and asks questions. It may not lead to an audit
AuditA formal examination of your records, which can lead to amended assessments
Lodgment or payment follow-upOverdue returns, BAS or debts

Common audit triggers

  • Data matching. The ATO receives data from banks, share registries, crypto exchanges, property settlements, online platforms, payment processors and other government agencies.
  • Industry benchmarks. Small businesses whose income or costs fall well outside benchmarks for their industry, especially cash businesses.
  • Unusual claims. Deductions much higher than others in your job or industry.
  • Lifestyle vs income. Assets and spending that do not match reported income.
  • GST refunds. Large or repeated GST refunds.
  • Late lodgments and a pattern of unpaid debts.
  • Known focus areas, such as rental property claims, working from home claims, personal services income and unpaid super.

The steps in an audit

  1. Notification. The ATO writes to you or your tax agent, explaining what it is looking at and what it needs.
  2. Information request. You provide records, often within 28 days. You can ask for more time.
  3. Interviews or site visits, in some cases.
  4. Position paper. The ATO sets out its preliminary view. You can respond with more information.
  5. Finalisation. The ATO closes the audit with no change, or issues amended assessments.
  6. Penalties and interest. Applied to any shortfall, based on your behaviour.

Simple reviews can be resolved in weeks. Full audits can take months.

Penalties at a glance

BehaviourBase penalty on the shortfall
Failure to take reasonable care25%
Recklessness50%
Intentional disregard75%

Penalties can be reduced if you make a voluntary disclosure, especially before the audit starts. Interest also applies and is no longer deductible.

Your rights

  • To be treated fairly and professionally under the taxpayers’ charter
  • To have a registered tax agent represent you
  • To ask for more time to provide information
  • To object to an amended assessment and seek review

How to prepare

  • Keep records for at least five years, in an organised system
  • Reconcile your bank accounts with your accounting software regularly
  • Make sure every large or unusual claim has paperwork behind it
  • Talk to your accountant as soon as the ATO contacts you, before you reply
  • Consider audit insurance, which can cover professional fees for responding to the ATO

Frequently asked questions

How far back can the ATO audit?

Usually two years for individuals and small businesses, four years for others. There is no limit for fraud or evasion.

Should I talk to the ATO myself?

You can, but it is wise to get your accountant involved before you respond, so your answers are accurate and complete.

What happens if I cannot find my records?

The ATO may deny the claims or estimate your income. Rebuild what you can from bank and supplier records.

Does an audit mean I did something wrong?

No. Many audits are triggered by data matching or random selection and close with no change.

Have someone in your corner

Pace Advisory Group represents clients in ATO reviews and audits across Melbourne, from first letter to final outcome.

This is general information only, not personal tax advice. Rules are current as at November 2026.

More Related Articles